“I think I know a way we can make this more interesting” was what Amy Greenwood said during their poker game. It was already an entertaining housewarming party, despite the fact it was so last minute nobody else could come, and their poker game was on the verge of becoming intense. But they weren’t prepared for when their girlfriend proposed to raise the stakes.
And the stakes were an evening in bed with her.
On the surface, not unusual. The three of them were in a polyamorous relationship, making both Ned Willis and Levi Kanning Amy’s boyfriends, so they were no strangers to competing over her. They had thought they had gotten past that. But now she was sparking that competition anew. She started it simple, strip poker. If one of the boys lost all their clothes first, the other got to spend the night with her. So they took the bet. The game lasted over an hour. Too their surprise, it was Amy who lost the game. She stared at both her boys in their briefs as she removed the last article of clothing from her naked body. She didn’t feel any shame, in fact felt delighted as how they eyed her hungrily.
“So…what does this mean?” Ned asked.
“I think that’s obvious” Levi grinned, a cocky tone on his voice as he shared a glance with Amy. “We both win.”
She looked at both of them, a smile growing on her lips.
Moments later, she was leading both of them into the bedroom with her holding each of their hands. The light was off but the living room glowed bright illuminating the bed clearly. Amy smiled as she came to a stop at the foot of the mattress, turning on her heels to look at the hot sexy young men standing in front of her staring at her naked body. Their awe made her giddy, excitement fluttering in her stomach. To think she had to be convinced into this polyamorous relationship, now she was ready to take both her lovers into bed at the same time. They stepped forward and caressed her skin, admiring her beauty as she took turns kissing them both.
Each had something different to offer and this was the first time she got to compare them at the same time, in the same breath. She kissed Ned and tasted something sweet, then Levi and found something salty. It was alluring having two pairs of hands roaming her body too, their palms fondling everything at the same time. She fell back onto the bed with a sigh, guiding her boys down with her where they continued to tease her, their mouths moving down her neck and collar as they lay either side of her. She looped her arms around their heads as they drifted over her breasts, each taking a nipple into their mouth making her moan. It was amazing having both her tits sucked at the same time, better than the usually alternating method. Then things got interesting when two different hands drifted down between her thighs seeking her sex. For a moment she wondered what they were looking for, but it seemed they had different objectives. One set of fingers found her clit, pitching and pressing it making her shiver. The other dipped lower and stroked the folds of her vagina, dipping inside making her shudder. Both left her gasping running her fingers through her hair as she tried to comprehend how crazy they were making her feel.
After a few slow satisfying seconds both Ned and Levi ended their pleasure and stood up, sharing a glance as they gazed at the whining young woman who was left disheveled. “I believe we were owed a happy ending after that game” Levi said crossing his arms.
“Yeah, feels like you’ve been getting the better part of this prize so far” Ned agreed, his hands on his hips.
Amy looked between the two of them pouting, pushing herself up from her comfortable lounge to sit on the end of the bed giving them an apologetic look. She might’ve gotten carried away with enjoying two smoking hot men in her bedroom. But she promised to make it up to them. For starters, she helped them each out of their underwear, pulling their briefs down their legs to their ankles. Each time she got distracted by the throbbing hard penis that spring out waiting for her. She stared at them both, one dark the other white, both thick and hard and begging for her attention. With a gulp of trepidation she reached out with both hands and took one cock in each. She couldn’t help but laugh at the absurdity of what she was doing. Giving each of them a sultry grin, she started stroking both of them with each hand, jerking off both boys at the same time.
It was strange, exciting and terrifying at the same time. They felt so different, each unique in their own way. She could feel the individual heartbeats through her palms coming from each cock. She looked up and saw them watching her, expecting more. She wanted to give them more, but didn’t know who should go first. She only had one mouth. She hated choosing, it was the whole reason she agreed into this polyamorous relationship in the first place. So instead she thought about it logically. What was the most logical choice.
Well, as it turned out, she was right handed, so she was more comfortable giving handjobs with her right hand. That meant her left hand was sloppy. So in this instant, her right lover, Ned, was getting the better handjob. So, logically speaking, it was only fair Levi got the first blowjob.
So that’s what she did. She leaned her head to the left, opened her mouth and took Levi’s cock into her mouth first. Her left hand lowered to his balls and fondled them while she sucked him off, meanwhile beating Ned’s cock with her stronger right hand. Levi moaned, grinning in delight as he watched his girlfreind take his cock vigorously. Ned shrugged, happy with the treatment he was receiving. She gave them approximately two minutes before switching her head over, moving her mouth to Ned’s cock and giving Levi a sloppy handjob.
She continued like that for as long as she could, losing track of how long they stood there or how many times she switched. Her head bobbed on one cock and then the other, pausing only to catch her breath before diving onto the next lucky winner. After a while both guys were panting, their hands stroking her hair and shoulders on the verge of unloading so of their sweet and salty love. Ned was the one to warn her first, Levi following soon after.
Amy did some more math in her head and suddenly pulled away from both of them before she could finish. “Wait, just hold it in” she said, releasing their cocks.
“I don’t think I can” Levi complained.
“Me neither” Ned groaned.
“Just wait” she said, holding up two fingers glaring at them both. The last thing she wanted was to be painted white like some Jackson pollock painting. She took her fingers and pointed to either side of the bed next to her, telling them “I have an idea. Over here, both of you.” They awkwardly shuffled across to stand at opposite sides of the bed while she climbed into the middle, turning on the spot deciding which way round she wanted to try first. She decided if Levi got to have the first blowjob, then Ned should get to fuck her first. “I prefer my sperm in my pussy, not my mouth. Just FYI” she said as she lined herself up so her ass was facing Ned’s throbbing erection and her back faced Levi.
She looked at Ned, signaling him to come closer as she opened her legs for him. He took the sign and stepped forward, taking hold of her ankles and opening them wider, letting her guide his penis into her entrance releasing a grateful sigh. Once he was inside, she arched her spine back craning her neck over the edge of the mattress so her head was vertical with the floor. Then she reached out and beckoned Levi to step forward and helped in find her mouth. From this angle, his dick slipped past her tongue and into her throat. Luckily she didn’t have a gag reflex so she took it all without complaint.
The boys looked at each other and marveled as they spit roasted their girlfriend, her body spread across the bed with her torso on full display. Ned brought her ankles together and thrust his hips against her ass, fucking her slick loose pussy enjoying it very much. Levi reach down and massaged her breasts while she stroked his bottom, his hips rutting against her face fucking her throat. It was a weird experience, but he dug weird. All he had to do was focus on her naked body and not on the naked man across from him. Ned did the same, keeping his eyes down watching his cock sink deeper and deeper into her pussy.
After a few moments of vigorous fucking, Amy felt the thrusts of her lovers begin to slacken as tension built. They were approaching the verge of climax again. Fortunately Ned was faster than a Levi, so she got to continue swallowing his penis until the artist howled unloading his cum into her body. They both knew she was on the pill so she had no fear about being knocked up at this moment. She moaned around Levi feeling the sperm swim through her vagina, her walls clamping together keeping it inside until the boy finished.
Once he did she slapped Levi’s thigh and got him to retract his throbbing cock out of her throat. He whined again, but complied letting her inhale sharply before sitting up on the bed. Keeping her legs together, the blonde woman smiled at the relived young artist and rolled onto her knees, teasing him with a playful kiss on the cheek. Giving him a minute to recover, she shuffled back until her ass was lifted in front of a desperate Levi wiggling welcomingly, her pussy dripping with white substance.
The cop didn’t even notice as he rushed to get his dick inside this woman, grabbing her hips and stuffing her full with his erection. “Oh my GOD!” Amy gasped as Levi immediately started fucking her, desperate to cum and get it over with. Her body shook with each thrust, her torso flung forwards onto her elbows with her face dangling in front of Ned’s semi. She stared at it a moment trying not to let her selfish indulgences comely her. But she gave in, taking Ned’s cock into her mouth to slavour it with her tongue while Levi took her from behind. Ned moaned watching his girlfriend suck him, his hands grabbing the back of her skull to thrust deeper into her throat, his cock enlarging in her mouth. She gulped as it slipped down her neck, deepthroating her until she was skewered between two lovers again.
Levi couldn’t last much long though. He came almost seconds after entering. He tried to hold it back, but doing so just made his balls expand faster. With a pained cry he ejaculated into her pussy, creaming her insides mixing his cum with Ned’s. Amy felt it fill her and she came too, her eyes crossing while Ned shoved her face into his crotch, dry heaving his empty balls into her mouth. The three of them held that position for a long minute until Levi was spent, his cock slipping out of her pussy deflated. Cum leaked from the hole while Ned pulled out of her mouth too, leaving the woman empty gasping for breath. She collapsed in a satisfied heap on the mattress, sprawling between the pair of them rubbing her fingers through her pussy coating them with their semen. She felt enthralled, powerful, gazing up at her boys like they were trophies. She could have either one she wanted, whenever she wanted.
This is what perfection is, she thought.
After a few minutes the three of them were back to full strength and sitting on the bed, naked and breathless staring at each other. “Well, that happened” Amy laughed.
“Yeah” Levi nodded, his demeanor still underwhelmed. “Still feels like you got the better outcome though” he remarked.
“Well what did you expect?” Amy asked. “I sucked both your cocks and you got to fuck me at the same time” she said.
“More like we took it in turns fucking you” Ned said.
“You both had your cocks in me” she reminded them. “My throat is actually raw.”
“Yeah, but there must be more we can do” Levi said.
Amy shook her head, telling them “unless you guys are asking to bum each other or something, I don’t see what else there is? Now, if you want to keep going, I’m willing to close my eyes and let you decide who fucks me next” she said, laying down on the bed closing her feet with her arms beneath her head. She closed her eyes and waited.
Ned and Levi looked at each other, sighing with annoyance. But then they stood up and decided to have a hushed whisper at the end of the bed. They came up with a plan they they were both on board with.
Moments later, Amy felt a body sit beside her. Before she could open her eyes though, she found herself being blindfolded. “We thought this would make things more interesting” Ned’s voice said.
“Ooh, sexy” Amy grinned. “Guess the boyfriend, I like this game” she joked, sitting up on the mattress waiting till the blindfold was tightly in place, her blond hair falling around it. “Bring it on” she said, ready and waiting. Out of her view, both her boyfriends smiled in anticipation.
The first body she felt was clearly Ned Willis. His hands were calloused and dry and his skin was rougher. And he had the unmistakable bristle of a beard when he kissed her. She hummed into his mouth as she was rolled onto her side, wrapping her arms around him making out with the boy. She felt his erection brush her sex, making the woman giggle when he lifted her knee along his hips to open her up for him. “What are you waiting for…Ned” she whispered in his ear when he paused.
“Just admiring the view” he remarked, gazing at her naked body in his arms before penetrating her pussy.
She gasped playfully, hooking her foot behind his back to grind up against him. He sheathed himself all the way he could, but held back against fucking her just yet. “Stop admiring the view and fuck it already” she whined. “I know I’m irresistible, but I won’t wait fo…hey, what are you..?”
“Hush babe” Levi whispered as he snuck in behind her. She knew it was him because his hands were soft, his skin was smooth, and Ned was still in bed with her.
Amy’s head darted to the side trying to look over her shoulder, forgetting she was blindfolded and unable to see anything. She felt his chest against her back as his hands reached around to grasp her boobs, making the woman gasp in surprise and pleasure. Then she remembered Ned was still here, meaning she was getting felt up by both her boyfriends at the same time. They’d never done that before. It was a rule. “What, stop, what’s going on? Why are you both..? Ah, hey, what are you..?”
Amy’s questioned went unanswered as the boys quickly made their play. While she stammered, Ned took hold of her ass and held her cheeks open, giving Levi a nice juicy target to aim as he inserted his erection into her anus. To his surprise the tip sank in almost immediately, and Amy froze from the intrusion. She wasn’t usually one for anal play, not since divorcing her second husband. But the feeling was familiar as her ass instinctively sucked him all the way in, leaving Levi sheathed up her back passage. “Whoa fuck, that feels amazing” Levi marveled.
“Oh shit” Amy gasped, realizing she now had both her boyfriends in bed with her and both their cocks were inside of her. She couldn’t help it, she reached up and whipped off the blindfold. “This is crazy. We have to stop!” She panted.
“Stop? We’re just getting started” Levi laughed, caressing her tits while his hips started to move, his cock sliding in and out of her anus.
“Yeah, and it feels really good” Ned agreed, finally thrusting his hips sliding his cock in her pussy.
Amy stifled a moan as she felt both cocks move inside her, balling her fists up holding back the pleasure. “I’m serious, we can’t…oh fuck…no, we shouldn’t be doing this. I won’t…oh my god…” she’d hadn’t been double penetrated for a long time, and she forgot how much her body loved it. It took everything to hold back a premature orgasm, which meant she lost steam to finish her complaint.
Ned and Levi understood though. They’d resisted the threesome idea for weeks. So they played on one of Amy’s biggest Ed in capabilities. “Do you really want us to stop?” Ned asked.
“Yes” she said.
“You want us to fuck you like we normally would” Levi asked.
“Yes” she said.
“Okay” Ned shrugged. “But I guess that means one of us will have to pull out.”
“So you’ll have to choose” Levi sighed. “Whose it going to be?”
“Oh no” Amy whined, her head falling to the pillow in frustration. They knew she wouldn’t be able to pick between them. It was the whole reason they started this polyamorous relationship. And her rational thoughts weren’t helping. Ned in her pussy felt nice, but so did Levi in her butt. And both of them together, their cocks rubbing together through her inner walls…
Ew, no, don’t think about that Amy’s mind screamed. Don’t think about your boyfriends cocks rubbing together. Oh god now you’re thinking about it and that’s all you can think about! Amy’s panic about becoming a gay husband magnet was coming true, she convinced herself. The smart play would be to shut this down and stop fucking both of them. But they feel so good her body complained.
Finally the woman gave up, reluctantly whimpering “okay.”
“Sorry, what was that?” Levi asked, making sure they all heard it correctly.
“Okay! Fine! You can both stay!” She said louder, earning an entertained chuckle from both her boys. “Just don’t think I’m going to enjoy it, okay” she bluffed
“Sure, of course not” Ned said, already seeing the pleasure she was trying to hide behind a pillow. He took her face and kissed her passionately, listening to her moan trying to make it sound like defeat rather than excitement. Levi kissed the back of her neck, happy to hump her ass as long as he got to play with her breasts.
For the next few minutes the three of them fucked like that, their bodies tangled around each other joined by the hip as the boys rutted against their girlfriend like horny dogs while she lay stay and let them fuck her. And she tried to fake it, but she really did love the feeling over having both their cocks inside her at the same time. It felt nice being sandwiched between them, like her own snuggly cocoon. It got better when she got to kiss her boys, easy with Ned but with Levi she had twist her neck around and pry one of her shoulders free of their entanglement. So many hands running over her, it was enough to drive a woman to orgasm. If this kept up, she soon would be driven over the edge.
The guys were loving this arrangement too, though it was getting difficult to fondle their girlfriend without their arms or hands colliding. They kept accidentally kicking each other when they tried to adjust their thrust pattern, and tried to be extra aware of where their hands were being placed. Ned almost found Levi’s arse on more than one occasion. And the less said about the fact both could feel the other guy’s cock through Amy’s body, the better. All they could focus on was Amy and the fun they were having stuffing her at the same time. So much fun their balls (which kept colliding with their opposites) were on the verge of emptying into those slick pulsing holes.
Ned paused in the middle of the sex to casually ask “hey, any chance we might be able to switch places soon?” He asked Levi, who was presently kissing Amy over her shoulder.
Before the policeman could reply, the blonde jumped in and said “nah uh, I’m not doing all this a second time. One gig thing. You picked the side, now just cum so we can finish.”
“I don’t know” Levi grinned. “I think I can hold out for a lot longer.”
“Cum now” she growled, her eyes darting warningly to them both, the look telling them their future with her was on the line. They got the message, adjusting their hold on her so they could fuck her even fast and harder. Amy moaned as both cocks thrust deeper into her at the same time, one pair of arms wrapped around her waist while another hooked around her shoulders, her body rocking like a jack hammer pinned between two handsome hunks. She’d be complaining about the headache she’d wake up with if she wasn’t too busy receiving a guilty orgasm. “Oh fuck me, yes!” She moaned, closing her eyes riding out the tidal wave of escasty.
Ned and Levi failed to notice their girlfriend climax. They did notice, however, when her walls clamped down around them squeezing their dicks harder. They both grunted, forcing themselves into her driving her sensitive holes over the edge. It drove them over the edge too, their balls aching. “Fuck, I think I’m going to…” Ned panted.
“Same here man” Levi grunted, clutching Amy tightly.
“Fuck, just cum in me!” Amy cried, desperation filling their voices as they rode out one massive simultaneous climax, cum flowing into one body before spilling out into the sheets between them. Their voices got choked out by moans and groans as they peppered out of steam, collapsing into one sweaty, heaving bundle of skin and limbs.
Once the climax was over, the three of them were left panting and heaving, their groins aching. Ned and Levi both had to unstable their arms to roll their dick out of Amy, flopping onto their back with a sigh. Amy could barely move as she limply colapsed between them, laying on her stomach with both her gaping holes leaking with cum. She felt sore, her anus in particular quivering. They didn’t say anything for several minutes as they regained their breath, the boys staring straight at the ceiling waiting for Amy to make the first move.
Eventually she was able to lift her head off the pillow, pushing herself onto her side brushing her hair above her brow exhaling slowly. Without looking at either Ned or Levi, she sternly told him “first, we are never doing that again. Second, we don’t tell anyone we did this. If they ask, it was just a party without sex.”
“One where I slept on the couch and Levi passed out in the bathroom?” Ned asked jokingly.
But Amy was in no mood for jokes, exhaling again before telling them “and third, you will both have to make this up to me, big time.”
Ned and Levi both looked at each other, then at their exhausted girlfriend. Somehow they knew they could live with whatever that was.
Comments